Clever Grades

🎧 Read Aloud

Tort Law: Defences and Remedies

Key Defences: Consent & Fault

🛡️

Volenti non fit injuria

To a willing person, no injury is done. Claimant consented to the risk of harm.
📋

Requirement

Consent must be informed and voluntary.
🏥

Medical Context

For medical treatment, patients consent to risks inherent in procedures.

Sport Context

In sport, participants accept risks inherent to the game.

Contributory Negligence Principle

Damages Award = Total Loss × (1 - Claimant Fault %)
Contributory negligence reduces damages when the claimant is partly at fault. The court apportions blame and lowers compensation accordingly.

Other Statutory and General Defences

1

Inevitable accident

Harm not preventable by any care.
2

Act of God

Natural events beyond human control.
3

Statutory authority

Conduct authorised by law.
4

Illegality

Claim barred if claimant engaged in illegal conduct related to the claim.
5

Necessity

Actions taken to prevent greater harm.

Remedies: Introduction to Damages

Goal of Compensation

Damages are monetary awards aiming to compensate the claimant. We will focus on how awards are calculated, including consideration of future losses and care.

Classification of Monetary Damages

The limitation period and dependency claims (in case of death) affect awards.

G

General damages

Cover pain, suffering, and loss of amenities.
S

Special damages

Cover quantifiable financial losses (e.g., medical costs, lost wages).

Policy Issues for Damages

⚖️
Policy issues for damages include ensuring just compensation without unreasonable burdens on defendants or insurers.
🏛️
This goal leads to discussions on caps and reforms.

Equitable Remedies: Injunctions

📜

Remedy Type: Equitable remedies like injunctions can order the defendant to do or refrain from doing something.

Prohibitory injunctions prevent harmful acts. Mandatory injunctions require specific actions to correct wrongs. Interlocutory injunctions are temporary, keeping the status quo pending trial.

Injunction Effectiveness and Limitations

The EffectivenessInjunctions are effective in protecting rights and preventing ongoing damage.
The CriticismMay be criticized for rigidity or difficulty of enforcement. Courts sometimes award damages in lieu of injunctions if injunctions are impractical or disproportionate.
```
Defences & Remedies Deck
Term
Volenti non fit injuria

What does "Volenti non fit injuria" mean?

Answer
Meaning

It means 'to a willing person, no injury is done,' indicating the claimant consented to the risk.

Term
Consent

When is consent considered valid under the volenti defence?

Answer
Requirement

Consent must be informed and voluntary.

Term
Contributory Negligence

How does contributory negligence affect damages?

Answer
Effect

It reduces damages when the claimant is partly at fault by apportioning blame and lowering compensation accordingly.

Term
Inevitable Accident Defence

What is an inevitable accident defence?

Answer
Definition

Harm caused by an accident that could not have been prevented by any amount of care.

Term
Act of God Defence

Define the act of God defence.

Answer
Definition

It applies when harm is caused by natural events beyond human control.

Term
Statutory Authority

What does statutory authority mean as a defence?

Answer
Meaning

The defendant's conduct was authorised by law, protecting them from liability.

Term
Illegality

How does illegality act as a defence?

Answer
Effect

Claims are barred if the claimant engaged in illegal conduct related to the claim.

Term
Necessity Defence

What is the necessity defence?

Answer
Definition

Actions taken to prevent greater harm justify otherwise wrongful acts.

Term
General Damages

What are general damages?

Answer
Definition

Compensation for pain, suffering, and loss of amenities.

Term
Special Damages

What are special damages?

Answer
Definition

Financial losses that can be quantified, such as medical costs and lost wages.

Term
Types of Injunctions

What are the main types of injunctions?

Answer
Types

Prohibitory (stop an act), mandatory (require an act), interlocutory (temporary pending trial).

Term
Damages vs Injunctions

When might courts award damages instead of injunctions?

Answer
Circumstances

When injunctions are impractical or disproportionate.

⚖️ Tort Law Quiz

1. What must be true for the defence of volenti non fit injuria to apply?

Consent must be informed and voluntary for volenti to apply.

2. Contributory negligence:

It reduces damages by considering the claimant’s share of blame.

3. Which of the following is NOT a recognised defence in tort law?

Mistake of law is generally not a defence in tort.

4. Which remedy orders a party to do something to correct a wrong?

Mandatory injunctions require specific actions.

5. The defence of illegality can be used when:

It bars claims connected to the claimant’s illegal acts.

📊 Results