Clever Grades

🎧 Read Aloud

Explanations for Obedience: Milgram's Findings

The Agentic State

Milgram's Agentic Shift

The agentic state explanation was proposed by social psychologist Stanley Milgram to describe why individuals obey authority figures even when asked to perform acts conflicting with their personal conscience. In an agentic state, individuals see themselves as agents executing the will or instructions of an authority figure rather than acting on their own volition.

When in an agentic state, individuals feel they are not responsible for their actions because the authority figure is seen as responsible. This relieves moral tension or guilt associated with harmful actions because responsibility is displaced.

Agentic vs Autonomous

🤔
What is the opposite of the Agentic State?
🦉
It's the autonomous state, where individuals act independently and accept responsibility for their actions.
🦉
Milgram argued that people shift between these states depending on the social context.

Key Concepts: Legitimacy

Legitimacy of authority refers to the societal or social group-based acceptance that certain individuals have a right to give orders and be obeyed.

⚖️

Right to Order

People are more likely to obey commands if they believe the authority figure has legitimate power.
👮

Formal Roles

Authority often comes from formal roles (e.g., police officers) and is supported by social norms or laws.
🔗

Facilitates Shift

Makes it easier for individuals to enter the agentic state and relinquish personal responsibility for their actions.

Milgram’s Situational Factors

Milgram manipulated these variables, demonstrating how environmental and contextual cues influence obedience rates significantly.

1

Proximity

Physical closeness between the participant (the 'teacher') and the victim (the 'learner').
2

Location

The perceived prestige and legitimacy of the environment where the study took place.
3

Uniform

The powerful symbol of legitimate authority worn by the person giving the orders.

Proximity Effect

⬇️
High Proximity (e.g., Touch)Obedience dropped sharply. The immediacy of the victim increases empathy, making it psychologically harder to obey harmful commands.
⬆️
Low Proximity (e.g., Phone)Obedience remained relatively high. The participant felt more distant from the consequences, reducing moral strain.

Location and Uniform Influence

📈

Location

Original prestigious university setting (Yale) lent legitimacy. When changed to a less prestigious office building, obedience rates dropped.
👔

Uniform

When the experimenter wore a lab coat (a sign of professional authority), compliance was higher compared to a person in ordinary clothes.

The Dispositional Approach

The Authoritarian Personality

Proposed by Adorno (1950s), this theory suggests that individuals with certain stable personality characteristics are more likely to obey authority figures and exhibit submissive behaviour towards them.

This personality is characterised by traits such as rigidity, conventionalism, respect for authority, and intolerance of ambiguity or weakness. Such individuals have an extreme respect for status.

Dispositional Measurement

🔍

The F-scale: The Fascism scale is the key measure used to assess authoritarian tendencies. This explanation complements situational factors, suggesting obedience results from the interaction of personality and external pressure.

```
Agentic State Explanation for Obedience
Term
Agentic State

What is the agentic state?

Answer
Explanation

A mental state where individuals see themselves as agents executing authority’s will, not acting on their own volition.

Term
Proponent

Who proposed the agentic state explanation for obedience?

Answer
Person

Stanley Milgram.

Term
Personal Responsibility

How does the agentic state affect personal responsibility?

Answer
Effect

Responsibility is displaced to the authority figure; individuals feel less guilt for harmful actions.

Term
Autonomous State

What is the autonomous state?

Answer
Definition

A state where individuals act independently and accept responsibility for their own actions.

Term
Reason for Agentic State

Why do people enter the agentic state?

Answer
Cause

Due to social context, especially in structured hierarchies with clear authority figures.

Term
Legitimacy of Authority

What is legitimacy of authority?

Answer
Definition

The societal acceptance that certain individuals have the right to give orders and be obeyed.

Term
Impact of Legitimacy

How does legitimacy of authority impact obedience?

Answer
Effect

It increases the likelihood that people will obey commands.

Term
Situational Variables

Name three key situational variables that affect obedience in Milgram's study.

Answer
Variables

Proximity, location, and uniform.

Term
Proximity

How does proximity influence obedience rates?

Answer
Effect

Closer proximity to the victim decreases obedience; remote proximity increases it.

Term
Uniform

How does uniform affect obedience?

Answer
Effect

Authority figures wearing uniforms elicit higher obedience than those in ordinary clothes.

Term
Authoritarian Personality

What is the authoritarian personality?

Answer
Definition

A personality type showing rigid respect for authority, conventionalism, and intolerance of ambiguity.

Term
F-scale

What scale measures authoritarian personality?

Answer
Name

The F-scale (Fascism scale).

Term
Interaction of Explanations

How do situational and dispositional explanations of obedience interact?

Answer
Explanation

Obedience arises from the combination of personality traits and external social pressures.

Tip: Tap a card to flip. Shuffle or Reset anytime.

🌸 Agentic State Explanation for Obedience Quiz

1. Who proposed the agentic state explanation for obedience?

Milgram developed the concept to explain why people obey destructive authority.

2. What happens to personal responsibility in the agentic state?

People feel they are merely agents and not personally responsible for their actions.

3. Which of these is NOT a situational variable that affected obedience in Milgram’s studies?

Personality is a dispositional factor, not a situational variable in Milgram’s experiments.

4. What effect does wearing a uniform have on obedience levels?

Uniforms legitimize authority and increase compliance.

5. The authoritarian personality is characterized by:

These traits make individuals more likely to obey authority figures.

6. What term describes the state in which people act independently and accept responsibility for their actions?

Opposite to the agentic state, where people take personal responsibility.

📊 Results

  • Notes and Quiz
  • Psychology
  • AS & A Level
  • Forgetting
  • AQA